Whats your team for the Pakistan Test series?

West Indies cricket discussions
User avatar
mikesiva
Posts: 19320
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 11:30 am
Location: Watford, Hertfordshire
Contact:

Unread post

AFRO wrote: 1. SHIV IS DONE!!..his war of words with the WICB has pretty much finished him off, SO GET OVER IT!!.

2. Yes i would pick Stoute over Shiv BECAUSE STOUTE IS AN ALLROUNDER, i know you're an advocate of damaging our bowling unit in order to fit your friend into the starting line-up BUT IT'S NOT GONNA HAPPEN.

3. Barath is apparently fit again and is working on his fitness so there's still a chance he might play in the Tests.

4. If Shiv was gonna be selected for the Tests he would have got the same recall Sarwan got for these ODIs, thank god that hasn't happened!! :mrgreen: .

Now my team would be

Brathwaite/Barath
Simmons
Darren
Sarwan
Nash
Carlos Brathwaite/Stoute or Bonner (if we want to play two spinners)
Baugh (wk)
Roach
Pascal
Edwards or Permaul (again if we want to two spinners)
Bishoo

The captaincy can go to either Nash or Sarwan, i believe a team like this is more than capable of getting a positive result.
Well, Brathwaite is now out of the squad after failing to make runs in the practice match, and Barath is still not back to full fitness. Sarwan had two bites of the cherry, but failed to pass 20 in each innings, and your number six selection is a joke!
:lol:
Hopes of Pascal and Permaul getting picked were premature, so we're back to where we started - Shiv has to play!
:D
User avatar
mikesiva
Posts: 19320
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2010 11:30 am
Location: Watford, Hertfordshire
Contact:

Unread post

AFRO wrote:Erm can't you read Mike? THE SRI-LANKA ODI's WERE IN 2011!!, which was part of Chanders shocking performances :roll:, but you can continue to distort my views if that makes you feel better,
So, you're going to pick a Test team based solely on ODIs?

Thank God you're not a WI selector....
:lol:
AFRO
Posts: 9502
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 12:44 pm

Unread post

mikesiva wrote:Well, Brathwaite is now out of the squad after failing to make runs in the practice match, and Barath is still not back to full fitness. Sarwan had two bites of the cherry, but failed to pass 20 in each innings, and your number six selection is a joke!
:lol:
Hopes of Pascal and Permaul getting picked were premature, so we're back to where we started - Shiv has to play!
:D
Oh look Mike is talking garbage IN HINDSIGHT again!!.. what a surprise!! :roll: , furthermore WHAT DID SHIV DO AGAINST PAKISTAN? oh yeah he wasted time at the crease again AND COULDN'T EVEN GET HIMSELF A 50!!.. and what did Samuels do? oh yeah HE SCORED A DOUBLE TON which is sure to make you nervous huh Mike? i'd advise you to KEEP PRAYING for your fellow pensioner!! :lol: .
Last edited by AFRO on Tue May 10, 2011 2:13 pm, edited 1 time in total.
AFRO
Posts: 9502
Joined: Mon Mar 28, 2011 12:44 pm

Unread post

mikesiva wrote: going to pick a Test team based solely on ODIs?

Thank God you're not a WI selector....
:lol:
Sigh!!.. yep i was right, it's seems like you just CAN'T READ!! :roll: ,

THE SL ODI SERIES IS JUST PART OF THE SHOCKING FORM SHIV HAS BEEN IN!!.. incase you didn't notice HE ALSO FAILED IN THE SL TEST SERIES!!.. but of course Mike likes to play dumb and act like that didn't happen!!.. i'm not shocked though!! :lol: .
cuffman
Posts: 73
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2011 10:59 am

Unread post

Let's look at who WILL PLAY this Thursday:

Sammy (captain) :evil:
Nash(vice captain)
Bishoo (spinner)
Baugh (the only keeper selected in the squad)
Darren Bravo (he's an essential member of the drive to rebuild)

Those 5, I think it's safe to say, will definitely start on Thursday. We are left with 6 other picks, this is how I think it will go:

Smith & Simmons (They are the only 2 openers selected in the squad, plus it'll be a major injustice to drop Simmons given the form he was in for the ODIs)

That's 7, 4 more...

IMO they should seek to strengthen the bowling attack if we are to have any hopes of forcing a win, draw cricket can't be an option. Hence IMO, all the quicks will start:

Roach
Edwards
Rampaul

That's 10. So, it'll be a toss up between Shiv, Sarwan and Samuels for the number 4 spot.

I think Sarwan right now is last in that race, hence IMO it's a toss-up between the out-of-form, but proven world-class veteran; and (potentially) the most prolific batsman right now in the region in the longer format.

Take your pick.

The squad may look as follows:

Simmons
Smith
Bravo
Shiv/Samuels
Nash
Baugh
Sammy
Rampaul
Roach
Edwards
Bishoo
netgrouchy
Posts: 6
Joined: Thu Mar 18, 2010 2:41 am

Unread post

Afro I have read through 8 pages on total bunkum from you. I detect that you have a one-track mind: get Shiv off the team!!!! He is old, he is no good, he had a bad series in SL - they had more rain than games .... Face reality: He has been selected for the two tests

I doubt you have any idea about the game of cricket and/or is history - West Indian cricket history and its recent collision with the WICB.

How dare you talk about Shiv opening his big mouth. Read Tony Cozier's recent article:
THE most implausible aspect of the latest in the age-old, never-ending, self-defeating conflicts between the West Indies Cricket Board (WICB) and its most prominent players is that Shivnarine Chanderpaul is at the forefront.

In the 17 years since he shuffled to the wicket at Bourda as a frail 19-year-old in his debut Test, Chanderpaul has never been embroiled in anything to tarnish his name or that of West Indies cricket, never been cited by a match referee, never appeared before a disciplinary committee. So what would have prompted such a seemingly placid individual to erupt, like a sleeping volcano, into such furious, lengthy outbursts, in print and on the airwaves, with the aid of his legal advisers, against the WICB, its chief executive Ernest Hilaire, coach Otis Gibson and the selectors?

And what can, indeed must, be done in the few days left before the Test series against Pakistan starts on Thursday to calm the troubled waters? On all the evidence, there were a few obvious catalysts to the dispute.

The first was Gibson's sharp censure of the unnamed but obvious "senior players" after the World Cup and his hint that they could be left out of the current home matches against Pakistan (as Chanderpaul, Gayle and Sarwan were). This was followed by Hilaire's general criticism of the attitude of some unidentified players in a radio interview.
The interviewer asked leading questions and provided a tremendous avenue/opportunity to get it out in the open so Shiv being inarticulate - just said it like it is..... He did not hold back and he is entitled to his emotions....

He openly admitted that the matter is HIS but he needed to liaise with WIPA so that he did not interfere with contractual issues and they put it in legalese. That was the one interview he did - everything else has mushroomed from that one but he cannot be held responsible for it. I actually think it has done a world of good for the team.

This now shows that the players cannot be taken for granted..... Jerome Taylor has had to go to IPL because no one approached him nor asked him to play in either the 5 ODIs or the 2 test matches..... His story is shocking too..... Nobody will speak for them so Shiv has opened up....

Shiv was also extremely supportive of Chris Gayle and Sarwan - I did not hear any one player speak out in support of SHIV..... Yes, the message boards, letters to editors in newspapers across the globe and private message like yours and mine are all out there but none could have touched the WICB as much as that one radio interview so kudos to the reporter who nabbed it.....

Give the man the respect he deserves... If you cannot find it within you to do so then simply shut YOUR big mouth and move on...........

Man up!!!!
User avatar
Googley
Posts: 5465
Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 1:05 pm

Unread post

you want to kill Afro with that post? :lol:
User avatar
BallOil
Posts: 19409
Joined: Thu Feb 04, 2010 11:12 pm

Unread post

Cuffman, are you serious? Baugh or Sammy batting at #6... :)
cuffman
Posts: 73
Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2011 10:59 am

Unread post

BallOil wrote:Cuffman, are you serious? Baugh or Sammy batting at #6... :)
It's not ideal, but that's what might happen if Sammy has to be accommodated. I chose to strengthen the bowling deliberately so that we give ourselves a chance to win, hence the batting had to be cut short because Sammy can't be dropped; a batsman had to make way for him.

If you are advocating strengthening the batting, then I hope you realise you will be a bowler short. Are you prepared to have that in a 5 day match?
User avatar
Googley
Posts: 5465
Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 1:05 pm

Unread post

squad:

Simmons
Samuels
Bravo
Sars
Shiv
Nash
Baugh
Sammy
Rampaul
Roach
Bishoo

Edwards is not an automatic pick...not just yet.
Post Reply