West Indies Cricket Fans

all that you list for shive is known and factored in.

if yu think it surpasses what those who have been listed ahead of shive have accomplished, you have the right to pick and post your alternative

I'm telling you that is a bogus alltime XI. What criteria they used to select the team? How many of them actually see Headley play his only 20 tests? How much test match the others played? What are they averages?

That lil fisherman Shiv will fish em out one by one

BallOil wrote:if Hendricks was that good would he make the alltime World XI?

he certainly would be listed among the world alltime greats, from among whom such would be selected!

I dont understand why you fighting hendricks? who would you prefer...proffer...Ramdin?

seriously Dujon was not a keeper in my book. I do not rate him among westindian greats.

Hendricks, Alexander, Muray ultimately, Jacobs etc.

Dujon did well but he was a transplanted batsman!

all in the world tell you about Hendricks...from the westindian players who played with Hendricks. Lloyd said so..now the cricinfo panel say the same thing?

do you believe anything anyone at all tells you no matter their credentials?

there must be something to the general agreement in the world over Hendricks..dont you think?

BallOil wrote:I'm telling you that is a bogus alltime XI. What criteria they used to select the team? How many of them actually see Headley play his only 20 tests? How much test match the others played? What are they averages?

That lil fisherman Shiv will fish em out one by one

whats the difficulty here again with headly?

there are forensic sciences that apply to the past of all and everything in the world that produces accurate answers about the world that humans work with everyday.

if forensic science was worthless we would be in a lot of trouble would'nt we!

and it is not as if Headly lived a million years ago...just a 100. most of us here were born while he still lived!

I dont like the side because of Hunte before Fredericks...and no mention of Butcher...and no real consdieration of the qualties of valentine and Ramadin and their extenuating circumstances.

I dont like the side as well because of presentation of a list candidates to the judges to choose from by misinfo.

but I do not think they did wrong by shive and hendricks!

Them pulled those names from a hat bro..

Shiv played many more tests than em... a 100 more than Headley

There must be a scientific way to select the team than asking a few jokers for their opinions